CNN iReport CNN iReport

The Brilliance of Nominating Sotomayor

May 26, 2009 | Wichita Falls, Texas | Vetting explained

RStewartIII Posted by:
RStewartIII

  • Viewed 448 times
  • Shared 9 times
  • Last updated: May 26, 2009
 
iReport —

Today, President Barak Obama announced his pick to replace Justice Souter on the US Supreme Court.  This person is Judge Sonia Sotomayor, a judge on the 2nd Court of Appeals.  While it is hard to say whether this is a good choice, it is a brilliant nomination choice for.

 

1>  President Obama has chosen a nominee that will have little-to-no opposition from the Democratic majority in the Senate.

 

2>  While Justice Souter is a moderate-to-liberal justice, Obama is basically setting up a more liberal stance with a younger judge that can be on the Supreme Court for at least 18-25 years. This can also set Sotomayor up for Chief Justice because of her potential longevity in the Supreme Court.

 

3>  The race/sex card.  While it is often repeated and emphasised that her nomination is not based on sex/race, everyone knows that this is a card that will be played.  Anyone who brings up either sex or race will set themselves up for being labeled sexist or racist, tarnishing their reputation.  While sex/race/religion should not make a difference, we would be ignorant to not understand how this can be used by both sides, and with the Republicans/Conservatives in the minority in the Senate, this will certainly be brought up to discredit their opposition to Sotomayor.

 

4>  Opposing opinion states that Sotomayor is an 'activist' judge, and would possibly be a justice that legislates from the bench.  However, I think that if this is her style, then Obama may be setting up the start of a Supreme Court that harkens back to the days of the Warren Court.

 

While I have yet to voice my personal opinion about Sotomayer's nomination, I wanted to visit the reasonings behind the appointment, which are sure to ensure Sotomayor's appointment as a Supreme Court Justice.

Comments

Log in to comment

iReport welcomes a lively discussion, so comments on iReports are not pre-screened before they post. See the iReport community guidelines for details about content that is not welcome on iReport.

What is iReport?

  • Share

    Tell a story, offer an opinion, say what's important to you.

  • Discuss

    Join the conversation on the day's big issues.

  • Be heard

    The best iReports get vetted and used on CNN platforms.

iReport is a user-generated section of CNN.com. The stories here come from users. CNN has vetted only the stories marked with the "CNN" badge. MORE...