Racial Issues and playing the "race-card"
A standard Obama comment about Republican attacks, combined with
a McCain ad regarding Britney Spears and Paris Hilton, has brought
race to the fore for the first time in this general election.
During Obama's primary battle against Sen. Hillary Clinton,
we wrote: "When race becomes more important, Obama suffers. To the
extent Obama looks like 'the black candidate,' he has slim support
outside his two bases of black voters and white hard-core
liberals." To some extent, that is true today.
Obama made a mistake by bringing up race.
The maxim that race is a loser for Obama, however, is less true
in the general election than it was in the primary, where
"electability" was a chief reason for Democrats to worry about
Obama's race. Before the Iowa caucuses, many supporters of Clinton
or John Edwards argued that Obama's skin color made him
unelectable.
Obama's recent comments-that Republicans would attack him on
the grounds that "he doesn't look like all those other presidents
on the dollar bills," was an echo of an earlier charge that GOP
attacks boil down to "and did I mention he's black?" It's important
to note both of these jabs were made before white audiences.
This suggests Obama is trying to stoke white guilt. (The
alternative-that he is trying to stoke black resentment-is simply
not believable, given Obama's track record.)
The main effect of Obama's accusing his rivals of planning
race-based attacks against him is to make critics wary of harshly
criticizing him. This is part of his strategy of creating the rules
of debate: It is off-limits as the "old politics" of division to
talk about abortion, the continued terrorist threat, Obama's
record, or his inexperience. The "did I mention he's black?" slur
is the second half of this strategy: Label all character critiques
as racial, in the hope of preserving the pristine reformer image he
has crafted for himself.
McCain's campaign hit back hard, accusing Obama of "playing
the race card." This forced Obama's campaign to implausibly deny
that he was accusing McCain of attacking him on racial grounds. The
Obama campaign's immediate tack to the defensive, however, shows
their understanding that a front-page discussion of race is a loser
for them. Obama's campaign would benefit from discussing race only
among supporters and off the record with the media, but on a
broader scale-in a very white country with many voters still wary
of a black president-talking about race still hurts Obama.
McCain's ad comparing Obama to pop stars Britney Spears and
Paris Hilton was juvenile and petty in itself, but it could
accomplish its goals. The message of the ad was that, like these
celebrities, Obama is famous more for being famous than for any
accomplishments or skills. The reaction by liberal writers and
bloggers, sniffing out racism and anti-miscegenation innuendo in
the ads was ridiculous and self-defeating. If Obama's backers
continue to cry "racism," it will hurt Obama more than it will
silence his critics.
While Obama may have success with his broader strategy of
setting down the "rules" for the campaign-the campaigns may only
talk about Iraq, the economy, and George Bush-this attempt to blend
all character criticisms with racial attacks was heavy handed, and
it backfired on Obama.
http://www.humanevents.com/article.php?id=27931#continueA